Biden Vaccine Rules to Unleash a Flurry of Legal Disputes

Biden Vaccine Rules to Unleash a Flurry of Legal Disputes

Republicans swiftly denounced the mandate that could impact 100 million Americans as government overreach and vowed to sue, and private employers who resist the requirements may do so as well. Texas Gov. Greg Abbott called it an “assault on private businesses” while Gov. Henry McMaster promised to “fight them to the gates of hell to protect the liberty and livelihood of every South Carolinian.” The Republican National Committee has also said it will sue the administration “to protect Americans and their liberties.” Such cases could present another clash between state and federal authority at a time when Biden’s Justice Department is already suing Texas over its new state law that bans most abortions, arguing that it was enacted “in open defiance of the Constitution.”

The administration is gearing up for another major clash between federal and state rule. But while many details about the rules remain unknown, Biden appears to be on firm legal ground to issue the directive in the name of protecting employee safety, according to several experts interviewed by The Associated Press. “My bet is that with respect to that statutory authority, they’re on pretty strong footing given the evidence strongly suggesting … the degree of risk that (unvaccinated individuals) pose, not only to themselves but also unto others,” said University of Connecticut law professor Sachin Pandya. The White House is gearing up for legal challenges and believes that even if some of the mandates are tossed out, millions of Americans will get a shot because of the new requirements — saving lives and preventing the spread of the virus.

Biden is putting enforcement in the hands of the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, which is drafting a rule “over the coming weeks,” Jeffrey Zients, the White House coronavirus response coordinator, said Friday. He warned that “if a workplace refuses to follow the standard, the OSHA fines could be quite significant.” Courts have upheld vaccination requirements as a condition of employment, both before the pandemic — in challenges brought by health care workers — and since the coronavirus outbreak, said Lindsay Wiley, director of the Health Law and Policy Program at American University Washington College of Law.

Where Biden’s vaccine requirements could be more open to attack is over questions of whether the administration followed the proper process to implement them, she said. “The argument that mandatory vaccination impermissibly infringes on bodily autonomy or medical decision making, those arguments have not been successful and I don’t expect that to change,” Wiley said. “I think the challenges that are harder to predict the outcome of are going to be the ones that are really sort of the boring challenges about whether they followed the right process.” Emergency temporary standards — under which the rules are being implemented on a fast track — have been particularly vulnerable to challenges, Wiley said. But the risks presented by the coronavirus and the existence of a declared public health emergency could put this one “on stronger footing than any other ones past administrations have tried to impose that have been challenged in court,” she said.

Indeed, the question of whether the mandate is legally sound is separate from whether it will be upheld by judges, including by a conservative-majority Supreme Court which has trended toward generous interpretations of religious freedom and may be looking to ensure that any mandate sufficiently takes faith-based objections into account. Vaccination “has become politicized and there are many Republican district judges who might be hostile to the regulation for political reasons,” said Michael Harper, a Boston University law professor. “I could imagine an unfortunate opinion that attempted to justify this political stance by rejecting the use of OSHA against infectious disease rather than against hazards intrinsic to the workplace,” Harper wrote in an email.

The News Highlights

  • Biden Vaccine Rules to Unleash a Flurry of Legal Disputes
  • Check the latest update on business news
Disclaimer: If you need to edit or update this news from compsmag then kindly contact us Learn more

For Latest News Follow us on Google News


Latest Headlines
  • Show all
  • Trending News
  • Popular By week
‘Pokémon Unite’ is now available on Android and iOS, according to TechCrunch
‘Pokémon Unite’ is now available on Android and iOS, according to TechCrunch
The game also introduces Unite Squads, which allow trainers to team up with squads.Trainer, according to Pokemon Company Can be createdSearch for your own ...
More about the love of money
More about the love of money
Imagine how healthy and happy everyone could be if compassion and justice were prioritized over love of money in our country’s health care system. ...
The SWAT standoff in Old Town comes to an end once authorities discover the call was a hoax; ‘my phone was hacked’
The SWAT standoff in Old Town comes to an end once authorities discover the call was a hoax; ‘my phone was hacked’
A SWAT team standoff in Old Town ended Wednesday afternoon after police learned the initial call to 911 was phony.Officers were initially called around 1:30 ...
Winery construction during COVID complicated by material price increase |  local news
Winery construction during COVID complicated by material price increase | local news
Your membership makes our reporting possible. Support Local Journalism {{featured_button_text}} What ...
Emory Healthcare CEO to Attend Health Connect South 2021 Key Panel |  Emory University
Emory Healthcare CEO to Attend Health Connect South 2021 Key Panel | Emory University
WHAT:Health Connect South 2021 To take part in the virtual conference, visit this link to register, free of charge.  WHEN:Thursday, Sept. 23 from 8 a.m. to 5 ...
Business Student introduces Podcast Featuring Prominent Alumni
Business Student introduces Podcast Featuring Prominent Alumni
Throughout his first podcast introduction, Wilkinson’s coronary heart price spiked. He was so nervous that the manufacturing group later needed to decelerate ...
Android TV 11 and the Redmi smart TV series with Dolby audio have been released in India
Android TV 11 and the Redmi smart TV series with Dolby audio have been released in India
In terms of specifications, the 32-inch and 43-inch Redmi smart TVs feature a Full HD (1,920 x 1,080 pixels) screen with a standard 60Hz refresh rate and a ...
Apple and Billie Eilish Collaborate on Short Film Promoting Spatial Audio
Apple and Billie Eilish Collaborate on Short Film Promoting Spatial Audio
Based on Dolby Atmos, Spatial Audio provides a surround sound experience, making songs sound like they are coming from all around you. Thousands of Apple ...
ASUN imposes penalties on teams with outbreaks of COVID
ASUN imposes penalties on teams with outbreaks of COVID
While the ASUN has made this ruling, it is far from the first college conference to do so as most conferences have adopted a similar policy of trying to keep ...
Taiwan Asks to Join Trade Group, Says China Might Meddle
Taiwan Asks to Join Trade Group, Says China Might Meddle
The CPTPP, which took effect in 2018, includes agreements on market access, movement of labor and government procurement. Other members include Australia, ...
Show next
Compsmag - Latest News from tech, business and health
Logo