Big Tech does not have Bipartisan Consensus

Big Tech does not have Bipartisan Consensus

But beyond their triumphant headlines, many of these articles note (often clumsily) that the “consensus” is merely an opinion that some kind of regulation for Big Tech is needed. This is where the idea of “bipartisan consensus” crumbles, and where the danger in this expression lies.

Finally, we’ve reached bipartisan consensus on Big Tech, yay everyone! At least that’s the line the press is echoing ad nauseum. “Facebook Whistleblower Reignites Bipartisan Support for Curbing Big Tech,” the Financial Times trumpeted last week after Frances Haugen’s Senate testimony on Facebook. “Lawmakers Send Big Tech a Bipartisan Antitrust Message,” Newsweek wrote a day later. For more than a year, but especially after last week’s US Senate hearing, the media has been increasingly suggesting that Democrats and Republicans are setting aside their long-standing disagreements on tech policy.

It’s true that in the past few years American lawmakers have become far more outspoken about Silicon Valley technology giants, their products and services, and their market practices. Yet merely agreeing that something must be done, and on that alone, is about as superficial as bipartisan consensus gets. Elected representatives of both parties still have disagreements about what that something is, why that something should happen, and what the problems are in the first place. All these factors are shaping both the proposed regulations in Congress and the path forward to making them reality.

On top of this, the media separating national politics from the tech legislation process only threatens to repeat the problems of the last several decades, where imagining technology as non-political is conducive to regulators and society ignoring dangers right in front of them. This overblown rhetoric skews analysis of the difficult road ahead to real, substantive regulation—and just how many threats to democracy (and democratic tech legislation) lie from within.

For decades, liberal democracies from the United States to France to Australia consistently touted the internet as a free, secure, and resilient golden child of democracy. US leaders in particular, from Bill Clinton’s Jell-O-to-a-wall speech in 2000 to the State Department’s so-called internet freedom agenda of 2010, hailed the web’s power to topple authoritarianism worldwide. Left alone, this logic went, democratic governments could enable the internet to be as pro-democracy as possible.

The groundswell of calls to regulate Big Tech today is no small change. While it’s tempting to see this shift as unilateral, some parts of the media often forget that tech is not a monolith and that many disparate incidents have led to many disparate calls for regulation: the Equifax data breach, the Cambridge Analytica privacy scandal, Russian ransomware attacks, Covid misinformation, disinformation campaigns targeting Black voters, uses of racist and sexist algorithms, abusive police uses of surveillance technology, and on and on. Not all lawmakers care equally, or at all, about these issues.

Data breaches and ransomware would seem to be two areas with the greatest potential for consensus legislation; members of Congress hardly stand up to profess their belief in lowering the cybersecurity bar and making their constituents vulnerable to attacks. Earlier this year, after multiple, significantly damaging ransomware attacks launched from within Russia, members of both parties condemned the behavior and highlighted how Congress and the White House could respond by sanctioning Russian actors and investing more in domestic security. The House and Senate held ransomware hearings in July, building on important civil society work to drive bipartisan responses to the threat.

The News Highlights

  • Big Tech does not have Bipartisan Consensus
  • Check the latest update on Security news
  • .

Disclaimer: If you need to edit or update this news from compsmag then kindly contact us Learn more

For Latest News Follow us on Google News


Latest Headlines
  • Show all
  • Trending News
  • Popular By week
Bartomeu blames Laporta for Barcelona's poor financial management
Lev Parnas convicted of funneling foreign money into US campaigns
Muraviev has not been charged with any wrongdoing. “Make no mistake, the purpose behind this conspiracy was influence-buying,” Scotten said, according to Law ...
Apple privacy changes hit ads business as Snap shares plunge 25%
Apple privacy changes hit ads business as Snap shares plunge 25%
The Santa Monica, California-based company, which earns the vast majority of its revenue from selling digital advertising on the app, said the issue was ...
California Plan to Prohibit Community Oil Drilling Far From Final
California Plan to Prohibit Community Oil Drilling Far From Final
Newsom’s administration pointed to studies that show living near a drilling site can elevate the risks of birth defects, respiratory problems and other ...
Bitcoin briefly plummeted 87% to about $8,000 on Binance’s US crypto-trading platform
Bitcoin briefly plummeted 87% to about $8,000 on Binance’s US crypto-trading platform
“One of our institutional traders indicated to us that they had a bug in their trading algorithm, which appears to have caused the sell-off,” Binance.US said ...
PAC uses Missouri governor’s attack on paper to increase money
PAC uses Missouri governor’s attack on paper to increase money
The newspaper last week found a security flaw that allowed the public to view the Social Security numbers of thousands of teachers through the state ...
Over-ear Headphones Market 2021
Over-ear Headphones Market 2021
Panasonic, Anker, Beats, Sony, Betron, Skullcandy, Vogek Over-ear Headphones Market competition by top manufacturers as follow: The global Over-ear ...
The Samsung Galaxy Buds 2 earbuds just hit their lowest price
The Samsung Galaxy Buds 2 earbuds just hit their lowest price
Which makes them more expensive than the original Galaxy Buds but less than the Galaxy Buds Pro that launched in January this year. It should be noted that ...
The Descent – The Dark Pictures Anthology: House Of Ashes Review
The Descent – The Dark Pictures Anthology: House Of Ashes Review
Much like its predecessors, Supermassive’s latest also uses real myths and historical events to flesh out its supernatural elements. House of Ashes begins in ...
Secretary of State warns of misleading business direct mail
Fast-food chain fines in Bay Area County for checking vaccines
San Francisco’s public health department temporarily shuttered the company’s Fisherman’s Wharf location Oct. 14, saying that the restaurant was endangering ...
Official: The narrative of passengers filming train rape is false
Official: The narrative of passengers filming train rape is false
Stollsteimer’s recount of surveillance video and plea to witnesses came after days of authorities saying multiple passengers were present for the assault, ...
Show next
Compsmag - Latest News from tech, business and health
Logo