Money & the Law: Legal Waters Muddle when State and Federal Laws Conflict | The business

Money & the Law: Legal Waters Muddle when State and Federal Laws Conflict |  The business

Source gazette.com Jim Flynn is with the Colorado Springs firm of Flynn & Wright LLC. You can contact him at moneylaw@jtflynn.com.

The trial court and the Court of Appeals sided with Melissa on this issue and held that ERISA’s preemption of state law applies to both the basic termination-on-divorce part of the statute and the can-be-sued-to-give-it-back part of the statute. So, Melissa gets to keep the money. However, the Court of Appeals ruled the position taken by Charles’ personal representative in the litigation was not frivolous and refused Melissa’s request for an award of her attorneys fees. To further confuse things, the Colorado statute has an additional provision saying that, if an ex-spouse receives a distribution because federal law has preempted the basic termination-of-beneficiaries-on-divorce rule, the ex-spouse receiving the distribution can be sued and required to give back the money. It’s this latter provision that Charles’ personal representative relied on when suing Melissa. Although previous court decisions had made it clear ERISA’s preemption of the basic termination-on-divorce statute is effective, this can-be-sued-to-give-it-back part of the statute had never been tested. Thus, the question for the courts became: does ERISA also preempt this must-give-it-back add on to the basic statute?

The lesson from this case would seem to be clear. For parties going through a divorce, the issue of beneficiary designations needs to be specifically addressed and the Colorado statute saying beneficiary designations are canceled on divorce cannot be relied on, especially if the beneficiary designation was created as part of an employee benefits plan. If Charles had changed the beneficiary designation on his life insurance policies after the divorce and before his death, this lawsuit never would have happened and Charles’ estate would have received the $535,000, to be distributed in accordance with the terms of his will. Now, to bring the law into play, Colorado has a statute that says beneficiary designations of any sort, including life insurance beneficiary designations, are canceled when a divorce decree enters. However, the federal Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), which was applicable here, says an administrator of an employee benefits plan must honor the beneficiary designations in place at the time a distribution is made, with no mention of divorce. And, ERISA goes on to say it preempts any state law to the contrary.

The News Highlights

  • Money & the Law: Legal Waters Muddle when State and Federal Laws Conflict | The business
  • Check the latest News news updates and information about business, finance and more.
Disclaimer: If you need to edit or update this news from compsmag then kindly contact us Learn more

For Latest News Follow us on Google News


Latest Headlines
  • Show all
  • Trending News
  • Popular By week
Thousands protest coronavirus blockades in Australia: NPR
Thousands protest coronavirus blockades in Australia: NPR
SYDNEY — Thousands of people took to the streets of Sydney and other Australian cities on Saturday to protest lockdown restrictions amid another surge in ...
A healthcare worker who was hospitalized for a month with COVID-19 says she now has nearly $1 million in medical bills
A healthcare worker who was hospitalized for a month with COVID-19 says she now has nearly $1 million in medical bills
She was hospitalized for a month and was placed in a medically-induced coma, according to the media outlet. During this time, she racked up an eye-watering ...
Frito-Lay strike ends when union members ratify contract
Frito-Lay strike ends when union members ratify contract
Workers said the shifts were caused by a severe staffing shortage at the plant. Carolyn Fisher, spokeswoman for PepsiCo., Frito-Lay’s parent company, said ...
Heritage Financial (NASDAQ: HFWA) must pay a dividend of $0.20
Heritage Financial (NASDAQ: HFWA) must pay a dividend of $0.20
The company’s dividend history has been marked by instability, with at least 1 cut in the last 10 years. Since 2011, the dividend has gone from US$0.12 to ...
Anthem Blue Cross Discards Dignity Healthcare Institutions Because of Contract Dispute |  local news
Anthem Blue Cross Discards Dignity Healthcare Institutions Because of Contract Dispute | local news
The dispute means that Dignity hospitals, medical groups and clinics will not be deemed in-network for those seeking care. Anthem has identified a number of ...
Sensata Technologies Reports First Quarter 2021 Financial Results
Telstra’s bid by Digicel Pacific based on achieving ‘adequate financial return’
Chinese-owned telco operators including China Mobile and ZTE are also reportedly interested in buying Digicel Pacific, which has 3G and 4G mobile phone ...
In mid-2022, a MacBook Air with a mini-LED screen upgrade will be available
Before we say our goodbyes, the Intel 16-inch MacBook Pro is around €2000
The MacBook Pro 16″ still dominates the MacBook M1 in graphics and in some other aspects (number of Thunderbolt ports, number of managed displays…), but we ...
Influencer falls 160 feet to her death on a livestream while showing off to admirers with her phone still in her hand
Influencer falls 160 feet to her death on a livestream while showing off to admirers with her phone still in her hand
The tower crane operator, who went by the online handle Xiaoqiumei, had more than 100,000 followers, regularly shared videos of her daily life and occupation ...
Arizona loses in attempt to use federal COVID relief funds for tax cuts |  Arizona and regional news
Arizona loses in attempt to use federal COVID relief funds for tax cuts | Arizona and regional news
Humetewa also rejected Brnovich’s contention that the sheer size of the proffered funds from the feds — $4.7 billion — amounted to illegal coercion given that ...
MORNING BUSINESS REPORT: Student loan is not worth it, help with internet account, large wind farm News
Israeli airlines launch first direct flights to Morocco
Israel and Morocco agreed to normalize relations in late 2020 as part of the U.S.-brokered “Abraham Accords.” Morocco was among four Arab nations, including ...
Show next
Compsmag - Latest News from tech, business and health
Logo