The dangers of processing encryption exchanges after ransomware attacks

The dangers of processing encryption exchanges after ransomware attacks

This flexible approach meant that AA was able to obtain injunctive relief. Bitfinex duly froze the account and provided AA with information about the identity of the customer who owned the wallet with the stolen BTC. In the AA case, Justice Simon Bryan determined — for the first time — that Bitcoin could be classified as property under British law, meaning that he could grant a proprietary injunction in relation to that property. This seems obvious, but traditionally the law has seen property as something that could either be possessed in a tangible sense or be enforced by a right to sue. Cryptocurrency obviously does not meet either requirement, but the courts have taken a pragmatic approach to ensure that novel intangible assets, like cryptocurrency, are considered property. As it turned out though, the BTC had been transferred again before Bitfinex was contacted by AA’s lawyers, and could not be returned. AA reached a confidential settlement with Bitfinex’s customer (also a defendant to AA’s claim) and then turned its sights on Bitfinex, in an attempt to receive additional compensation. The insurer raised a number of legal claims against Bitfinex, including the assertion that the exchange received the BTC (or its traceable proceeds) when it was property belonging to AA. As such, AA declared that a legal trust should be imposed, holding Bitfinex accountable to AA for the BTC. It was also argued that Bitfinex was reckless with regards to whether the BTC was lawfully transferred into the relevant wallet.

Norwich Pharmacal orders, which require a third party to disclose certain information to the applicant that will assist in recovery efforts. In this context, the information would be the identity of the wallet holder to which the BTC was traced, and/or details of any other transactions involving the BTC since receipt by the wallet linked with the exchange.Freezing orders that prevent defendant fraudsters from dealing with any of their assets until further notice. An exchange notified of a freezing order relating to a client must take steps to freeze the account to prevent the client from withdrawing and dissipating assets.Where it can be established that the third party holds property that belongs to the fraud claimant, proprietary injunctions can be obtained to prevent the third party from dealing with that particular property. Linked orders are often made to require the subject of a proprietary injunction to disclose information of the Norwich Pharmacal-kind explained above.Cryptocurrency as property in the U.K. Having traced the stolen BTC to Bitfinex’s platform — and with the identity of the hackers still unknown — AA started its litigation against Bitfinex in December 2019. Again, this is not unusual: U.K. courts have a wide range of remedies at their disposal to assist victims of fraud in trying to recover their assets. In instances where banks, exchanges or other intermediaries may find themselves unknowingly receiving or holding misappropriated or stolen assets, victims of fraud have been able to rely on:

The U.K. courts are very familiar with the preceding remedies when involving bank accounts and fiat currency. More recently, the courts have been grappling with how these principles apply to cryptocurrency. However, it is clear that the courts are willing to flexibly apply legal principles, to ensure that these remedies are available to victims trying to recover stolen crypto assets. So far, this story is (unfortunately) far from unusual. Bitcoin accounts for the vast majority of ransomware payments due to its anonymity, accessibility (making it easier for victims to pay the ransom) and verifiability of transactions (allowing criminals to confirm once payment has been made). What is unusual about this story, however, is that it sparked a 14-month-long legal battle between AA and Bitfinex, one that only recently concluded after AA discontinued its claim against Bitfinex in the U.K. High Court.

Cyber insurers like AA might calculate that the cost-benefit associated with those steps would be justified. However, exchanges like Bitfinex will continue to defend themselves robustly, particularly when the legal merits of claims are extremely challenging, and ultimately represent an attempt to drag an innocent exchange into the fallout of a cybercrime it had neither knowledge of nor involvement in. This article was co-authored by Stephen Elam and Shelley Drenth. It is understandable that victims of fraud — who may not be able to successfully pursue the actual fraudster — might be tempted to take on a cryptocurrency exchange with deep pockets, perhaps in the simple hope that they can engineer a modest settlement, and avoid the time and cost of complex legal proceedings.

Conclusion These are difficult arguments to prove, and after Bitfinex sent out its detailed legal defense and response to AA’s claims, AA ultimately decided to abandon its claims against Bitfinex. But this was not quite the end of the story. Usually, when a claimant abandons its case, the default position is that it must pay all of the defendant’s costs. However, AA argued that its cost liability should be reduced by 50%, based upon Bitfinex’s supposedly “unreasonable” conduct. The parties fought this out at a High Court hearing in January, culminating in the court deciding there was no unreasonable conduct that would justify any reduction. AA was therefore ordered to pay 100% of Bitfinex’s legal costs, including the costs of its own unsuccessful application to have those costs reduced.

The News Highlights

  • The dangers of processing encryption exchanges after ransomware attacks
  • Check the latest News news updates and information about business, finance and more.
Disclaimer: If you need to edit or update this news from compsmag then kindly contact us Learn more

For Latest News Follow us on Google News


Latest Headlines
  • Show all
  • Trending News
  • Popular By week
Mustang Bio Announces FDA Acceptance of IND Application for

Mustang Bio Announces FDA Acceptance of IND Application for

News HighlightsThe Phase 1/2 multicenter study to assess the safety, tolerability and efficacy of MB-106 in patients with relapsed or refractory CD20+ ...
Health secretariats have notified 188 new cases of COVID-19 in Quad-Cities since Friday |  Local News

Health secretariats have notified 188 new cases of COVID-19 in Quad-Cities since Friday | Local News

The Henry and Stark County Health Department and the Henry County Office of Emergency Management announced a special Friday, May 14 second-dose Pfizer Covid-19 ...
No, Apple is probably not working on a rival Nintendo Switch 2

No, Apple is probably not working on a rival Nintendo Switch 2

The idea that Apple will suddenly get in on the portable gaming space – a notoriously hard nut to crack, even for established players like Sony – just doesn’t ...
Certified Personal Trainer, health coach and mother of a small town find strength in reality news TV

Certified Personal Trainer, health coach and mother of a small town find strength in reality news TV

SOURCE Jill May Media Contact: Jill May 1-612-655-8739 Related Links About Jill May For more information on Jill’s story, along with up-to-the-minute news ...
Adafruit’s RP2040 Powered Keyboards

Adafruit’s RP2040 Powered Keyboards

Adafruit’s KB2040 is an Arduino Pro Micro pin compatible board that offers the power of the RP2040 for your next keyboard build. Keeb Boar is a 3 x 4 ...
Cleer Enduro ANC Headphones With Battery Backup For 60 Hours And Effective Noise Cancelling

Cleer Enduro ANC Headphones With Battery Backup For 60 Hours And Effective Noise Cancelling

The very best ANC headphones are made by the likes of Bose and Sony but they are quite expensive. However, thanks to improved technology using hybrid ANC ...
Ellume Establishes Flagship U.S. Manufacturing Facility in

Ellume Establishes Flagship U.S. Manufacturing Facility in

News HighlightsEllume establishes state-of-the-art diagnostic manufacturing facility in Frederick, Maryland, which is on track to begin limited operation ...
Lebanese-American citizen guilty of money laundering and tax crimes |  USAO-EDVA

Lebanese-American citizen guilty of money laundering and tax crimes | USAO-EDVA

Both defendants are scheduled to be sentenced on September 21. Farhat faces a maximum combined penalty of 25 years in prison, and Hawi faces a maximum five ...
BNY Mellon Markets appoints Laide Majiyagbe head of finance and liquidity

BNY Mellon Markets appoints Laide Majiyagbe head of finance and liquidity

ABOUT BNY MELLONBNY Mellon is a global investments company dedicated to helping its clients manage and service their financial assets throughout the investment ...
Global Agrigenomics Market Size & Share Will Reach to USD

Global Agrigenomics Market Size & Share Will Reach to USD

News HighlightsNew York, NY, May 10, 2021 (News) — Facts and Factors have published a new research report titled “Agrigenomics Market By Technology ...
Show next
Compsmag - Latest News from tech, business and health
Logo