The US Supreme Court sides with Google in the copyright dispute with Oracle over Android code

The US Supreme Court sides with Google in the copyright dispute with Oracle over Android code

But the Supreme Court sided 6-2 with Google, describing the copying as ‘fair use.’ The outcome is what most tech companies — both large and small — had been rooting for. Both Microsoft and IBM were among the industry heavyweights that had filed briefs backing Google in the case. They and others warned that ruling against the
Mountain View, California-based company could have profound consequences, stifling innovation and upending software development. Oracle had won backing from the movie and recording industries as well as publishers, which favour expansive copyright protections to protect their profits from books, articles, movies, TV shows and music. The Trump administration had also backed Oracle.

Technology companies sighed with relief Monday after the Supreme Court sided with Google in a copyright dispute with Oracle. The high court said Google did nothing wrong in copying code to develop the Android operating system now used on most smartphones. To create Android, which was released in 2007, Google wrote millions of lines of new computer code. It also used about 11,500 lines of code copyrighted as part of Oracle’s Java platform. Oracle had sued seeking billions. In his opinion for the court’s majority, Justice Stephen Breyer wrote that Google “took only what was needed” and that “Google’s copying was transformative,” a word the court has used “to describe a copying use that adds something new and important.”

Google had said its actions were long-settled, common practice in the industry, a practice that has been good for technical progress. It said there is no copyright protection for the purely functional, noncreative computer code it used, something that couldn’t be written another way. But Austin, Texas-based Oracle argued Google “committed an egregious act of plagiarism.” The case has been going on for a decade. Google won the first round when a judge rejected Oracle’s copyright claim, but that ruling was overturned on appeal. A jury then sided with Google, but an appeals court again disagreed.

Breyer wrote that in reviewing the lower court’s decision, the justices assumed “for argument’s sake, that the material was copyrightable.” “But we hold that the copying here at issue nonetheless constituted a fair use. Hence, Google’s copying did not violate the copyright law,” he wrote. At one point in the decision, Breyer used a recipe-finding robot as part of an analogy to explain how code works. At another point, he invoked a one-sentence short story to acknowledge that copying a small amount could still be significant. Breyer included both the story, originally in Spanish, and its translation: “When he awoke, the dinosaur was still there.”

Justice Clarence Thomas wrote in a dissent joined by Justice Samuel Alito that he believed “Oracle’s code at issue here is copyrightable, and Google’s use of that copyrighted code was anything but fair.” Only eight justices heard the case because it was argued in October, after the death of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg but before Justice Amy Coney Barrett joined the court. In a statement, Google’s chief legal officer, Kent Walker, called the ruling a “victory for consumers, interoperability, and computer science.”

The News Highlights

  • The US Supreme Court sides with Google in the copyright dispute with Oracle over Android code
  • Check the latest world news updates and information about business, finance, technology and more.
  • Check the latest update on tech news
Disclaimer: If you need to edit or update this news from compsmag then kindly contact us Learn more

For Latest News Follow us on Google News


Latest Headlines
  • Show all
  • Trending News
  • Popular By week
Onxeo reports financial results for 2020 and provides business updates

Onxeo reports financial results for 2020 and provides business updates

This extensive and ambitious R&D program reflects the significant potential of our candidates in multiple combinations and therapeutic areas. Finally, ...
Onxeo reports the financial results for the year 2020 and provides business updates on the Paris Stock Exchange: ONXEO.PA

Onxeo reports the financial results for the year 2020 and provides business updates on the Paris Stock Exchange: ONXEO.PA

This extensive and ambitious R&D program reflects the significant potential of our candidates in multiple combinations and therapeutic areas. Finally, the ...
The Great Ace Attorney Chronicles Comes Westward July 27 for PS4, switch and PC

The Great Ace Attorney Chronicles Comes Westward July 27 for PS4, switch and PC

Source The Great Ace Attorney Chronicles will release on PlayStation 4, Switch and PC on July 27th. In a new message from Creator Shu Takumi, it was ...
What news of Samsung Galaxy S11 is leaked?

What news of Samsung Galaxy S11 is leaked?

First up: the renders. As usual with early phone renders, these are not official renders from the company but are instead from leaker OnLeaks. OnLeaks is a ...
Sharps Containers Market Size 2021

Sharps Containers Market Size 2021

News Highlights Pune, India, April 22, 2021 (News) — The increasing need for effective waste management is a key factor driving the global “sharps ...
Renewable energy, well-being and your portfolio

Renewable energy, well-being and your portfolio

New studies show there are health implications linked to the inhalation of polluted air. Research in Spain even links air pollution to mental health and ...
Apple bans party app, China loses 39K iOS games, TikTok births a ‘Ratatousical’ – TechCrunch

Apple bans party app, China loses 39K iOS games, TikTok births a ‘Ratatousical’ – TechCrunch

Due to COVID-19, time spent in apps jumped 25% year-over-year on Android. Apps aren’t just a way to pass idle hours — they’re also a big business. In 2019, ...
Probably exit window for cryptographers, old transactions being under the scanner

Probably exit window for cryptographers, old transactions being under the scanner

According to new company rules notified in March, corporates should disclose any profit or loss on transactions involving cryptocurrency, cryptocurrency ...
Santa Rosa commercial printer ChromaGraphics names Derek Knell sales executive

Santa Rosa commercial printer ChromaGraphics names Derek Knell sales executive

The print and direct marketing company said Knell will be focused on development of business in Marin County. It stated he is a Marin County native with over ...
Home caregiver sentenced to one year for identity theft

Home caregiver sentenced to one year for identity theft

The investigation was conducted by police detectives from Edwardsville, Belleville, Swansea and the St. Clair County Sheriff’s Office. The case is being ...
Show next
Compsmag - Latest News from tech, business and health
Logo