The war of the experts between Apple and Epic Games gets personal

Apple vs. Epic Games is a war of experts that gets personal

Apple has called its own experts to rebut Evans’ views on the market, but with an added personal twist: It called MIT economist Richard Schmalensee, who has authored numerous books and academic papers together with Evans, to accuse Evans of contradicting his own prior research.

SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) – In its ongoing case against Apple Inc, “Fortnite” creator Epic Games is counting on this week’s testimony from its star expert witness David Evans, chairman of Global Economics Group, to make its case that Apple is an anticompetitive monopolist over app developers.

Legal experts said Apple’s aim was to chip away at Evans’ credibility in the eyes of the judge who will rule on the case.

The erstwhile collaborators – who together have written works cited extensively by the U.S. Supreme Court in landmark antitrust decisions – are duking it out over the central issue in the three-week trial in federal court in Oakland, California: What is the relevant market in the case?

Framed Epic’s way, Apple and its app store are a monopoly that is abusing control over the mobile software market to extract commissions for payments made inside apps. But Apple argues that it is just one of many competitors in a healthy market for video game purchases.

Whichever side prevails in persuading Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers on the question of market definition will likely win the entire case, antitrust experts said.

“Epic absolutely has to win the market definition,” said Daniel Lyons, a professor at Boston College Law School. “If Apple is right that ‘Fortnite’ on iOS is just one small part of the larger ‘Fortnite’ universe, then Apple doesn’t have market power and anything they do is unlikely to cause consumer harm because consumers can switch.”

On the stand this week, Evans testified that Apple is what is known as a single-brand market, arguing that once consumers buy an iPhone, the costs of switching to an Android are so high that they rarely make the jump.

Since about 2010, Evans testified, Apple’s App Store has effectively been its own market, and users rarely venture outside. After Apple kicked “Fortnite” off the App Store, Evans testified, only a small fraction of Apple users jumped to other devices like PCs or gaming consoles to play “Fortnite.” Schmalensee, by contrast, contends that the relevant market is gaming transactions, where Apple is just one platform among many – Microsoft Corp’s Xbox and Sony Group Corp’s PlayStation – sitting between game developers and gamers and charging commissions to facilitate transactions.

Apple’s App Store is a two-sided marketplace, Schmalensee testified, a concept that he and Evans have written about extensively, including in an amicus curiae brief on behalf of American Express in a 2018 U.S. Supreme Court case. American Express had prohibited merchants from steering their customers toward rival cards with lower swipe fees, arguing that its higher fees helped fund cardholder perks that benefited consumers. The court sided with American Express, citing Evans and Schmalensee extensively in its decision.

Schmalensee said Apple’s rules that prohibit apps from steering consumers to less costly payment presented an almost identical issue, and that Evans had contradicted many aspects of his previous work. Outside observers have been surprised by the split between the two star economists.

“I would say (Evans’) views on AmEx haven’t changed, but what he would say is the facts here are different and so the same result isn’t appropriate,” said Geoff Manne, president and founder of the International Center for Law & Economics research center. “Personally, I don’t see how he gets there and gets it to stick.”

The News Highlights

  • The war of the experts between Apple and Epic Games gets personal
  • Check the latest update on Gaming news
Disclaimer: If you need to edit or update this news from compsmag then kindly contact us Learn more

For Latest News Follow us on Google News


Latest Headlines
  • Show all
  • Trending News
  • Popular By week
How about 'Monkey Business' in Clinton?

Great Tech critique Lina Khan to lead the US competition regulator

Khan’s 2017 paper “Amazon’s Antitrust Paradox” took aim at the corporation’s growing power, particularly its role as both logistics provider and competitor to ...
Tharayil Finance promoter, who cheated Rs 2.5 crore investors, surrenders in Kerala – The New Indian Express

Tharayil Finance promoter, who cheated Rs 2.5 crore investors, surrenders in Kerala – The New Indian Express

Source www.newindianexpress.com This is the second NBFC in Pathanamthitta that has duped a large number of investors in recent times. Popular Finance, another ...
Companies are still struggling to find employees

Companies are still struggling to find employees

“Georgia turned off or is going to turn off the federal rider at the end of June. We’ve seen an up tick in our applies because of that reason. Companies have ...
A Company Fined more than £100,000 after it imported fake Apple chargers

Apple’s App Store has once again been chastised for censoring LGBTQ+ apps

Mainland China is in second place with 27 of the apps banned in the App Store, followed by the UAE with 25, Ghana with 24, and Nigeria with 23. At the other ...
Low-income homes ‘must get help from ultra-fast gigabit broadband’

Low-income homes ‘must get help from ultra-fast gigabit broadband’

The government should offer vouchers to low-income homes to encourage the take-up of ultra-fast gigabit broadband, a report suggests. The Gigabit Take-up ...
The PS4, Switch, and PC versions of Super Robot Wars 30 have been announced

The PS4, Switch, and PC versions of Super Robot Wars 30 have been announced

Play-Asia previously listed a game last year with the title “Super Robot Wars (30th Anniversary)” for PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4, and Nintendo Switch. The ...
Feel the Good Electronic Dance Music House

Feel the Good Electronic Dance Music House

The simple concept: You just need to play your song on a good home computer with a good sound card and a good midi interface. You can use VST or Windows ...
New behavioral health clinic for children opens in Las Vegas

New behavioral health clinic for children opens in Las Vegas

The Autism Clinic for Kids is a comprehensive clinic designed to provide diagnosis, management and care of children of all ages with autism spectrum disorder. ...
Secretary of State warns of misleading business direct mail

New site tracks which colleges will use eproctoring software this fall

Also on the front page is a “webcam image test” meant to determine whether eproctoring algorithms could accurately identify a viewer’s face (following ...
Zuckerberg says the original Oculus Quest will have Air Link wireless streaming

Zuckerberg says the original Oculus Quest will have Air Link wireless streaming

According to UploadVR, the v30 update will also include the ability to create a bigger play space, with the Guardian system being updated to handle ...
Show next
Compsmag - Latest News from tech, business and health
Logo