Voices silenced at GST Council meeting, says West Bengal Finance Minister Amit Mitra

Voices silenced at GST Council meeting, says West Bengal Finance Minister Amit Mitra

  “Unfortunately, you decided not to agree with the suggestions of so many Ministers,” the West Bengal Minister told the Union Finance Minister. “The GST Council was to consider providing significant relief to the sufferings of the common people and the struggling health infrastructure… The consumers of the COVID materials in this hour of need would be greatly benefited with only a 0.1% GST,” he wrote. “As representatives of the people, we have no way to justify these decisions of draconian nature. Therefore, you have left me no option but to record my dissent against these anti-people decisions which will hurt millions of people who are struggling to breathe and survive this pandemic,” he emphasised.

“Whither GST Council!” Mr. Mitra remarked in a missive addressed to Ms. Sitharaman, marked to all State Finance Ministers.  

The West Bengal Finance Minister said that he, along with several Ministers, proposed zero-rating or imposing a 0.1% GST on COVID related materials for a limited period, keeping the likely third wave of infections in mind. Even former Bihar Finance Minister Sushil Kumar Modi, now a BJP MP in the Rajya Sabha, has recommended a 0.1% GST as a solution “cutting across party lines”, Mr. Mitra said. Mr. Mitra said he repeatedly tried to voice objections after Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman announced the Council’s decision as its chairperson, but “the Secretary brought the meeting to a close and the virtual link was cut off”.

Reminding Ms. Sitharaman that the meeting was being held in the backdrop of the death of 3.76 lakh people due to the pandemic in the country, of whom two lakh have died between January 16 and May 1, 2021, he said the Council’s “forced decision” would mean that GST is imposed on several items used today for fighting COVID-19. Last month, when West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee had urged the Prime Minister to drop GST levies on COVID supplies, Ms. Sitharaman had responded with a series of tweets against the idea and termed it “counter-productive”. “Obviously, this and other instances in today’s GST Council meeting have dealt a major blow to the spirit of cooperative federalism undermining the very ethos of the GST Council,” he noted.

“Instead, you gave the floor to the Minister from Uttar Pradesh (U.P.), who sought deletion of some of my comments by name and shockingly, you agreed. I could never imagine that this would come to pass in a GST Council meeting where my voice is muzzled, despite the restraint and decorum I have maintained in 44 meetings of the Council — truly unprecedented,” he pointed out. Stressing that he is writing to her “with great anguish”, Mr. Mitra said that Ms. Sitharaman referred to several of his observations towards the end of the Council’s meeting, but he was not allowed to respond.

The News Highlights

  • Voices silenced at GST Council meeting, says West Bengal Finance Minister Amit Mitra
  • Check the latest News news updates and information about business, finance and more.
Disclaimer: If you need to edit or update this news from compsmag then kindly contact us Learn more

For Latest News Follow us on Google News


Latest Headlines
  • Show all
  • Trending News
  • Popular By week
According to rumours, the new iPad mini would sport an 8.3-inch display with no home button
According to rumours, the new iPad mini would sport an 8.3-inch display with no home button
Young currently works as an industry analyst following stints in the display divisions of both GE and Samsung. Reports of late have suggested that Apple ...
Disney World and Disneyland will again require indoor masks regardless of Covid’s vaccination status
Disney World and Disneyland will again require indoor masks regardless of Covid’s vaccination status
— CNN’s Clare Duffy, Jacqueline Howard and Devan Cole contributed to this report. The news that masks are returning at Disney’s domestic parks also follows ...
Hannaford remembers some bakery products produced in stores
Hannaford remembers some bakery products produced in stores
No illnesses have been reported. Customers should not eat the product and can return items to the store for a full refund, officials said. Hannaford ...
Israel’s health system prepares for third dose of Covid-19 vaccine pending final government decision
Israel’s health system prepares for third dose of Covid-19 vaccine pending final government decision
A second new case was reported in Beijing on Thursday afternoon, with health authorities describing the two local cases as a husband and wife who had recently ...
Macron: France has a ‘debt’ with the Polynesians because of nuclear tests
Macron: France has a ‘debt’ with the Polynesians because of nuclear tests
Macron promised money for cyclone shelters to help the island territory cope with climate change, and more help in fighting the COVID-19 pandemic in a region ...
Oregon reports 6 more deaths related to COVID-19, 804 new cases
Oregon reports 6 more deaths related to COVID-19, 804 new cases
As of Wednesday, 2,477,608 people have had at least one dose of a COVID-19 vaccine and 2,302,395 people have completed a COVID-19 vaccine series. Oregon has ...
Police looking for stolen Chick-fil-A delivery car
Police looking for stolen Chick-fil-A delivery car
Police posted photos of the vehicle on social media, and are asking anyone with information to contact them. Georgia-based Chick-fil-A has more than 2,400 ...
Some people in Missouri are being vaccinated against Covid-19 in secret for fear of reactions from loved ones who are opposed to the vaccines, says the doctor.
Some people in Missouri are being vaccinated against Covid-19 in secret for fear of reactions from loved ones who are opposed to the vaccines, says the doctor.
Frase said her hospital had 33 patients admitted with Covid-19 as of Wednesday and she’s expecting that number to rise. Unvaccinated patients are getting ...
In terms of sales, Xiaomi trailed Samsung and Apple; how much market share did Xiaomi have?
In terms of sales, Xiaomi trailed Samsung and Apple; how much market share did Xiaomi have?
FOLLOW US: हिन्दी में पढ़ें Best Smartphones: Neither Samsung Nor Apple, This Company Emerges As Number 1; Know Details Representative Photo: Getty Images ...
Euphoric Philippines, Rewards Greet Olympic Gold Winner at Home
Euphoric Philippines, Rewards Greet Olympic Gold Winner at Home
The 30-year-old Diaz, who won gold in the women’s 55-kilogram category on Monday in her fourth Olympic appearance, will be able to collect her rewards once ...
Show next
Compsmag - Latest News from tech, business and health
Logo