Why is it so hard to be mean in video games?

Why is it so hard to be mean in video games?

Red Dead Redemption had an honor system, though if you pulled a bandana over your face, outlaw-style, you could commit murder, robberies, and other evil acts with impunity. In the sequel, your honor rating changes regardless of whether you hide your face. It has a more pronounced impact, changing the way people in the game react to you, the way the central character Arthur Morgan carries himself, and how things end. It used to be so straightforward. When I think back to games like Black & White, Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic, and Fable, there was no moral ambiguity. Every action had a judgment attached. For example, in Fable, the more atrocities you committed, the scarier you’d look to those around you. In other games, it would link directly to a points system.  As games have matured, morality systems have grown more complex. Many developers simply don’t give you the option of taking the high road anymore. Sometimes there’s so much gray you can’t see what’s right. It might be choosing the least bad path, rather than the good path.

“Fiction imitates life, and to create a believable world for an audience to immerse themselves in, it needs to contain some portrayal of a moral system,” Starks says. “Because if you have absolutely no wrong or risk of wrong, there is no conflict, and if you have no conflict, you have no story that an audience is interested in experiencing.” Without choice, things can get boring fast. It’s important to feel like you’re steering events and that you have some say over who your character is and where you’re going. That’s especially true in open-world games with the freedom of mobility and involved plots.

The Gray Area “We could say, ‘Well then, why bother making a less morally good path at all? That’s a lot of time and resources to develop a choice that most players won’t ever experience.’ But having the choice itself is what’s important,” Starks writes in an email. 

While Obsidian’s data might show its players are often choosing the good path, that doesn’t mean all gamers are usually on the side of right. A Baylor University study researched how people approach moral choices in video games and focused on three scenarios: Source Moral Choices

I spent a long time agonizing over whether to hook up the sole power station to Edgewater or the Botanical Lab in The Outer Worlds, knowing it would condemn the faction I didn’t choose. After a lot of back and forth, I managed to find a compromise that made both parties happy, persuading the leader of Edgewater to leave. But that depth of choice is rare. “If the choice is always easy, it becomes boring and also causes us to spend a lot of time developing content no one will experience,” Starks says. “If we make the choices ‘shades of gray’ or types of ‘good to neutral’ or ‘low-stakes jerkish,’ players are more likely to weigh the pros and cons of each and select more variety in the options.”

The News Highlights

  • Why is it so hard to be mean in video games?
  • Check the latest Gaming news updates and information about games.
  • Please share this news with your friends and family to support us your one share helps us a lot.
  • Follow us on Facebook and Twitter, for similar updates.
Disclaimer: If you need to edit or update this news from compsmag then kindly contact us Learn more

For Latest News Follow us on Google News


Latest Headlines
  • Show all
  • Trending News
  • Popular By week
Razer Opus X noise-canceling headphones challenge the top-rated brands like Sony, Bose, Apple

Razer reveals a more affordable version of its Opus headphones

The company is promising “punchy bass and crisp mids and highs” in Opus X, thanks to its tuned 40mm drivers. There’s a quick attention (or passthrough) mode ...
Municipalities face 'Rescue' money crunch |  News

Municipalities face ‘Rescue’ money crunch | News

Despite lobbying from Vermont’s congressional delegation, Gov. Phil Scott and the Vermont League of Cities and Towns, the Treasury Department has yet to alter ...
The Xbox Deals Unlocked Sale is now live, and here are some of the best games to pick up

The Xbox Deals Unlocked Sale is now live, and here are some of the best games to pick up

Microsoft just launched its Deals Unlocked Sale ahead of its forthcoming E3 2021 presentation this Sunday. The Xbox Store’s Deals Unlocked Sale offers huge ...
M1 iMac deal delivers a new Amazon all-time low price

M1 iMac deal delivers a new Amazon all-time low price

Apple 24-inch M1 iMac deal drops to new all-time low We’re heading into the weekend with all of today’s best deals, headlined by a new all-time low on ...
Study reveals alcohol consumption deals for under $17.5 billion

Study reveals alcohol consumption deals for under $17.5 billion

“If alcohol companies are truly committed to preventing youth drinking, they should be willing to put these revenues into an independent agency able to address ...
How much ransomware can affect our lives is just proved by colonial gas pipeline Hack

Colonial Pipeline Hackers Lost Ransom Due to a Mistyped Password

One of the factors taking the price down is the news that $2.3 million of the ransom was recovered by the FBI. At first, the news was interpreted to mean ...
Foreign hacking of America must be stopped, as well as handouts and other perks

Foreign hacking of America must be stopped, as well as handouts and other perks

Should these attacks continue, major offensive attacks that exceed the damage that these current cyberattacks have caused us should be initiated. We need to ...
Viva Gold changes financing terms

Viva Gold changes financing terms

About Viva Gold Corp.Viva Gold Corp. is a gold exploration and project development company with a focus on Nevada. Viva holds 100% of the advanced Tonopah Gold ...
Linux GUI programme functionality is now included in the Windows Subsystem for Linux

The Linux Foundation Public Health establishes the Global

The GCC schema definitions and minimal datasets will follow the recommendations of the Blueprint, as well as GCCN’s technical and governance documents, ...
OneLab Clipt Allows a Seamless Content Transfer from Android to Desktop

There’s no need for an iPhone: FaceTime will be available on Android and Windows in the near future

In iOS 15, you’ll be able to join a FaceTime call from your iPhone, Android or Windows device. Announced at WWDC, Apple’s iOS 15 update allows people with ...
Show next
Compsmag - Latest News from tech, business and health
Logo