Why is the Science Museum still being tainted by Shell’s dirty money? | Climate Change

Why is the Science Museum still being tainted by Shell's dirty money?  |  Climate Change

The company argues, correctly, that its targets are conditional on being “in step with society”. Otherwise it “will be trying to sell products that our customers do not want”. But by producing ads that exaggerate its commitment to reducing emissions, it seeks to assuage public opinion and, I believe, delay the demand for a transition from fossil fuels. In my view, the exhibition at the Science Museum has the same effect. Yes, we should explore any technologies that might help to prevent climate breakdown. But we should not allow them to be used as greenwash. Unless fossil fuel companies retire their reserves at a rate commensurate with preventing more than 1.5C of heating, they remain a lethal threat to human wellbeing and the survival of other lifeforms. So far, none of them, even on paper, have plans compatible with preventing more than 2C of heating, let alone 1.5C. Shell’s programme was criticised by environmental groups last week as being hazy and halfhearted. Worse still, while Shell has cut its ties with some lobby groups, it is still a member of several, such as the Consumer Energy Alliance and the Australian Petroleum Production & Exploration Association, which have sought to stymie climate policies. It hopes that much of its future profit will come from the rising production of plastics. Last year, the American Chemistry Council, to which Shell also belongs, lobbied for trade rules that would rip down Kenya’s strict measures on single-use plastic, and force the country to keep accepting plastic waste from other nations. It wanted to turn Kenya into “a hub for supplying US-made chemicals and plastics to other markets in Africa”.

As Culture Unstained (which seeks to bring oil sponsorship to an end) points out, most of the technologies the exhibition promotes are either speculative, extremely expensive or, despite ample opportunity, simply not happening. For example, carbon capture and storage (CCS) – extracting carbon from the exhaust gases of power stations, then piping it into geological formations – has been noisily promoted as a leading solution for 20 years. But so far only 26 plants of any kind are using it, and 22 of these are rigs using the CO2 they pump underground to drive more oil out of the rocks (a process called enhanced oil recovery). The exhibition, called Our Future Planet, emphasises the technologies that might capture the carbon dioxide from burning fossil fuels, or extract it from the air once it has been released. The Science Museum tells me that Shell had no influence over its design or content. I believe it, but to my eye the exhibition aligns neatly with oil company agendas. For years, oil firms have sought to delay the retirement of their reserves for as long as possible by emphasising technofixes. If carbon dioxide can be captured, this could buy time in which their discovery and drilling, landgrabs and leaks, pollution and profits can continue for longer than society might otherwise permit.

The commitments to CCS in Shell’s latest annual report are vague and generic. Yet many of its promises to cut net emissions rely on a combination of this technology and offsets. While capture technologies are generally failing to materialise, the scale of the necessary carbon cuts means that offsetting emissions is no longer viable. We need both to maximise the retirement of fossil fuels and maximise the drawing down of carbon, preferably through the rewilding of ecosystems. One is not a substitute for the other. Although many other great institutions – such as the National Galleries in London and Scotland, the Tate Galleries, the National Theatre, the Royal Shakespeare Company, the Southbank Centre, the American Museum of Natural History and the Van Gogh Museum in Amsterdam – have cut their ties with fossil fuel industries, the Science Museum seems determined to tar and feather itself. Its director, Sir Ian Blatchford, told journalists: “Even if the Science Museum were lavishly publicly funded I would still want to have sponsorship from the oil companies.” Something tells me this will not age well.

Source www.theguardian.com

This, I believe, is a zero-sum game. The credibility that Shell might gain from its association with the Science Museum is credibility the Science Museum loses. What Shell seeks, as its CEO admits, is “a strong societal licence to operate”. By sponsoring august cultural institutions, oil companies hope to normalise an ecocidal business model. In doing so, they contaminate anyone foolish enough to take their money. When I challenged the museum, it pointed me to an article by Blatchford, in which he argued, “we believe the right approach is to engage, debate and challenge companies … to do more to make the global economy less carbon intensive.” So do I. But how does accepting their funding help? It doesn’t exactly enhance your power, does it? “Do what we say or we won’t take your money any more.”

The News Highlights

  • Why is the Science Museum still being tainted by Shell’s dirty money? | Climate Change
  • Check the latest News news updates and information about business, finance and more.
Disclaimer: If you need to edit or update this news from compsmag then kindly contact us Learn more

For Latest News Follow us on Google News


Latest Headlines
  • Show all
  • Trending News
  • Popular By week
McAfee Maps Out How to Navigate Through New Security Landscape while American are busy scheduling the Summer Travel

McAfee Maps Out How to Navigate Through New Security Landscape while American are busy scheduling the Summer Travel

McAfee study shows consumers not putting their digital wellness first, despite increased tech adoption   News Highlights: 2 in 3 Americans report that ...
In Southern Indiana, mixed reaction on revoking the health bill veto |  News

In Southern Indiana, mixed reaction on revoking the health bill veto | News

Under SB 5, county commissioners would have to approve any local order during a public health emergency that’s more stringent than state executive mandates. It ...
Japanese finance and Tech Giant, GMO Internet Group, partners with Binance to bring the world’s first regulated Stablecoin ‘GYEN’ with JPY indexing to the masses |  national news

Japanese finance and Tech Giant, GMO Internet Group, partners with Binance to bring the world’s first regulated Stablecoin ‘GYEN’ with JPY indexing to the masses | national news

GMO Internet Group, based in Tokyo, is a global market leader in the Internet infrastructure, Internet finance and the digital asset space since its inception ...
How Brazil is reforming a public fund to finance broadband expansion

As Cholamandalam Finance’s resilience is put to the test, investors are cautious

* Thank you for subscribing to our newsletter. * Enter a valid email Never miss a story! Stay connected and informed with Mint. Download our App Now!! ...
Coyotes captured on Resident’s Camera in Los Altos

Coyotes captured on Resident’s Camera in Los Altos

“Nice names for the pups,” a Cupertino woman commented on Nextdoor. “Thank you for sharing the video. Always seen coyote as being harmful. So this video is ...
Xbox Game Pass’s Top Open-World Games

Xbox Game Pass’s Top Open-World Games

It could be said that open-world games encapsulate gaming’s best attributes and push them to their logical extremes — they offer fully fleshed-out alternate ...
The director of Europa Universalis 4 apologises for years of “poor quality launches”

The director of Europa Universalis 4 apologises for years of “poor quality launches”

Posting on the Paradox forums, Andersson admitted that Leviathan, the game’s most recent update, was “one of the worst releases we have had”. But this wasn’t ...
The developers of Roblox’s most famous game have launched a new studio

The developers of Roblox’s most famous game have launched a new studio

So it’s no surprise that the talent behind Adopt Me! has founded its own company called Uplift Games. Previously, the game’s development talent were ...
Show next
Compsmag - Latest News from tech, business and health
Logo