Table of Contents
The best detective games for Xbox were some of the first games ever made. This was mostly because they were point-and-click games that were easy to play on the limited hardware that was available when video games became popular.
Now, there are many various sorts of mystery games. In one of the most popular types, you can play detective and solve a case. One of the most popular types of mystery games is Best detective games for Xbox. As a detective in the game, you have to figure out how to solve a case.
Over the years, there have been several games with detective themes. We made a list of the best detective games for Xbox. This list should help you, whether you wish to play a detective who works for the police or an anti-hero who is set on getting his own back.
Best Detective Games for Xbox
| Game Title | Genre | Modes | Price | Official Website |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments | Adventure, Mystery | Single Player | $29.99 | Visit Website |
| Chicken Police: Paint it RED! | Adventure, Mystery | Single Player | $19.99 | Visit Website |
| The Wolf Among Us | Adventure, Mystery | Single Player | $14.99 | Visit Website |
| Disco Elysium – The Final Cut | RPG, Adventure | Single Player | $39.99 | Visit Website |
| Max Payne 2: The Fall of Max Payne | Action, Adventure | Single Player, Multiplayer | $9.99 | Visit Website |
| The Vanishing of Ethan Carter | Adventure, Mystery | Single Player | $19.99 | Visit Website |
| Lacuna | Adventure, Mystery | Single Player | $19.99 | Visit Website |
| The Darkside Detective: A Fumble in the Dark | Adventure, Mystery | Single Player | $12.99 | Visit Website |
Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments
| Minimum | Recommended |
|---|---|
| OS: Windows 7/8/10 (64-bit) | OS: Windows 10 (64-bit) |
| Processor: Intel Core 2 Duo 2.4 GHz or AMD equivalent | Processor: Intel Core i5 3.0 GHz or AMD equivalent |
| Memory: 2 GB RAM | Memory: 4 GB RAM |
| Graphics: DirectX 9 compatible GPU with 1 GB VRAM | Graphics: DirectX 11 compatible GPU with 2 GB VRAM |
| DirectX: Version 9.0c | DirectX: Version 11 |
| Storage: 14 GB available space | Storage: 14 GB available space |
You know that our list of the best detective games for Xbox would include a Sherlock Holmes game. In reality, we have two Sherlock Holmes games on our list, and the second one is towards the very end.
In Crimes and Punishments, you play as Sherlock Holmes and try to solve six different crimes. All six of these situations are really distinct from one other and will make you think in new ways.
- A deep story and interesting cases make this detective game fun to play.
- Good graphics and sound design create an atmosphere that pulls you in.
- There are many possible outcomes and choices that affect how the story ends, giving it replay value.
- Some players might find the controls and game mechanics hard to understand.
The Good
The Bad
Chicken Police: Paint it RED!
| Minimum | Recommended |
|---|---|
| OS: Windows 7 SP1 | OS: Windows 10 |
| Processor: Dual Core CPU | Processor: Quad Core CPU |
| Memory: 4 GB RAM | Memory: 8 GB RAM |
| Graphics: GeForce GTX 760 or equivalent | Graphics: GeForce GTX 960 or equivalent |
| DirectX: Version 11 | DirectX: Version 11 |
| Storage: 6 GB available space | Storage: 6 GB available space |
Chicken Police: Paint it RED! is a weird mix of best detective games for Xbox and a visual novel. You play as private investigator Sonny Featherland and his partner, Marty MacChicken, as they look into a case in the city of Clawville.
In this hard-boiled noir, you can follow them as they encounter people from the sleazy side of town, question suspects, and look into crime sites.
- The main characters are animals that have been made to look like people.
- A detective story with witty dialogue and a plot that keeps you interested.
- The immersive experience is made even better by the great voice acting and moody music.
- When there aren’t many ways to play and the same things happen over and over, it can get boring.
The Good
The Bad
The Wolf Among Us
| Minimum | Recommended |
|---|---|
| OS: Windows 7 | OS: Windows 10 |
| Processor: Intel Core 2 Duo 2.4 GHz | Processor: Intel Core i5 2.3 GHz |
| Memory: 3 GB RAM | Memory: 4 GB RAM |
| Graphics: Nvidia GTS 450+ with 1024MB+ VRAM (excluding GT) | Graphics: Nvidia GTX 550+ with 1024MB+ VRAM |
| DirectX: Version 11 | DirectX: Version 11 |
| Storage: 5 GB available space | Storage: 5 GB available space |
The Wolf Among Us is a game that was made by Telltale. If you’ve played any of the developer’s other games, you’ll know how the game works. The game is an adventure with separate parts, like a comic book.
Even though you don’t start off as a detective, you spend all five parts of the series looking into a case. So, the game is like other best detective games for Xbox in how it is played. If you like comic books, you’ll love hearing about what your favorite heroes and villains get up to.
- Based on the popular Fables comic book series, the story is compelling and grown up.
- Interactive storytelling and quick-time events come together in a unique way to make the game interesting.
- Some players might not like how there aren’t many ways to play and there aren’t any typical action sequences.
The Good
The Bad
Disco Elysium – The Final Cut
| Minimum | Recommended |
|---|---|
| OS: Windows 7/8/10 (64-bit) | OS: Windows 10 (64-bit) |
| Processor: Intel Core 2 Duo | Processor: Intel Core i5 or higher |
| Memory: 2 GB RAM | Memory: 4 GB RAM |
| Graphics: Integrated Graphics | Graphics: Nvidia GTX 970 or equivalent |
| DirectX: Version 11 | DirectX: Version 11 |
| Storage: 20 GB available space | Storage: 20 GB available space |
Role-playing is the type of game that Disco Elysium: The Final Cut is. The best detective games for Xbox takes on the role of a detective with his or her own set of skills. In this role-playing game, you choose what to do and how to do it.
To go where you need to go, you can sing karaoke, threaten, dance, bribe, fall in love, or become a rich. This game also has a new way of talking to characters that has won several game awards.
- Deep and immersive narrative-driven gameplay with unique dialogue systems.
- A well-written, complicated story with a lot of character growth.
- The beautiful hand-painted art and atmospheric music create a world that is hard to leave.
- Some players may not be able to play games with high system requirements.
- Some players might not like games that move slowly and have few action scenes.
The Good
The Bad
Max Payne 2: The Fall of Max Payne
| Minimum | Recommended |
|---|---|
| OS: Windows XP | OS: Windows 7/8/10 |
| Processor: 1 GHz Pentium III/Athlon or 1.2 GHz Celeron/Duron processor | Processor: 1.4 GHz Pentium 4/Athlon or 1.7 GHz Celeron/Duron processor |
| Memory: 256 MB RAM | Memory: 512 MB RAM |
| Graphics: 32 MB AGP graphics card with hardware transform & lighting support | Graphics: 64 MB AGP graphics card with hardware transform & lighting support |
| DirectX: Version 9.0 | DirectX: Version 9.0c |
| Storage: 1.5 GB available space | Storage: 1.5 GB available space |
Max Payne 2: The Fall of Max Payne is a single-player, third-person shooter video game made by Remedy Entertainment and released by Rockstar Games. It’s the next game in the Max Payne series, and it takes place in a made-up world.
The player takes on the role of the game’s main character, Max Payne, an NYPD investigator. After what happened before, the main character joins forces with Mona Sax and goes on an expedition to solve a plot of betrayal and death.
- With slow-motion bullet time, this third-person shooter is intense and fun to play.
- An interesting and cinematic story with memorable characters and an atmosphere that is reminiscent of noir.
- Impressive graphics and a realistic physics engine make the game feel like you’re really there.
- Compared to modern standards, the game’s graphics and mechanics may make it less appealing to some players.
The Good
The Bad
The Vanishing of Ethan Carter
| Minimum | Recommended |
|---|---|
| OS: Windows XP SP3 | OS: Windows 7/8/10 |
| Processor: Intel Core2 Duo or equivalent AMD | Processor: Intel Core i5 or higher |
| Memory: 4 GB RAM | Memory: 8 GB RAM |
| Graphics: DirectX9c compliant card with 512MB of VRAM | Graphics: DirectX11 compliant card with 1GB of VRAM |
| DirectX: Version 9.0c | DirectX: Version 11 |
| Storage: 9 GB available space | Storage: 9 GB available space |
The Vanishing series is an excellent example of how to merge best detective games for Xbox with themes that are generally found in action games. In The Vanishing of Ethan Carter, there are a lot of occult undertones, and they end up being a big part.
You are Paul Prospero in the play. You go to Ethan Carter’s residence after getting a letter from him. When you go there, you find out that he has already been killed. So begins your mission to find out who killed the man in such a horrible way.
- The game lets you explore a beautiful and eerie open world while focusing on solving mysteries.
- A unique way to tell a story that is interesting and draws you in.
- Some players might think that the game is slow and doesn’t have much going on.
The Good
The Bad
Lacuna
| Minimum | Recommended |
|---|---|
| OS: Windows 7/8/10 (64-bit) | OS: Windows 10 (64-bit) |
| Processor: Intel Core 2 Duo or equivalent AMD | Processor: Intel Core i5 or higher |
| Memory: 4 GB RAM | Memory: 8 GB RAM |
| Graphics: DirectX9c compliant card with 512MB of VRAM | Graphics: DirectX11 compliant card with 1GB of VRAM |
| DirectX: Version 9.0c | DirectX: Version 11 |
| Storage: 9 GB available space | Storage: 9 GB available space |
Lacuna is best detective games for Xbox about consequence. Everything moves forward with every option taken (or not made) and every issue solved. It’s an easy game to play since you always know what to do. The hard part is doing things the right way to get the result you want.
This gorgeous noir-themed pixel art side-scroller gives you a sensation of both success and failure thanks to its elaborate puzzles, great storytelling, and branching paths. Each of these feelings pulls you deeper into the game’s interesting jazzpunk drama.
- The gameplay is unique and immersive, with a focus on investigating and making choices.
- Story is interesting and has multiple endings and paths, so it can be played more than once.
- Some players might find that the game moves slowly and has a lot of talking.
The Good
The Bad
The Darkside Detective: A Fumble in the Dark
| Minimum | Recommended |
|---|---|
| OS: Windows 7/8/10 (64-bit) | OS: Windows 10 (64-bit) |
| Processor: Intel Core 2 Duo or equivalent AMD | Processor: Intel Core i5 or higher |
| Memory: 2 GB RAM | Memory: 4 GB RAM |
| Graphics: Integrated Graphics | Graphics: Dedicated graphics card with 1GB of VRAM |
| DirectX: Version 9.0c | DirectX: Version 11 |
| Storage: 2 GB available space | Storage: 2 GB available space |
The Darkside Detective: A Fumble in the Dark takes place shortly after the original game finishes. The main character, Detective Francis McQueen, is back. In the first of six new cases, Detective McQueen is trying to find his devoted but dim-witted partner, Officer Dooley.
Officer Dooley has been missing and is thought to be in the “Darkside,” a place where ghosts and strange animals live. The best detective games for Xbox of the story is still a lot like a mix of “Twin Peaks” and “Ghostbusters,” but the universe feels much more developed.
- Point-and-click adventure games with a supernatural twist that are funny and odd.
- Unique pixel art style and graphics that look like they came from the 1980s.
- Story is interesting, and the characters and dialogue are easy to remember.
- The linear gameplay and lack of branching paths make it hard to play again and again.
- Players who like high-quality graphics might not like games with simple graphics.
The Good
The Bad
FAQs
Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments, L.A. Noire, Batman: Arkham Knight, Murdered: Soul Suspect, and The Wolf Among Us are some of the top detective games for Xbox.
The first Sherlock Holmes game in the series is an open-world game with a visual aesthetic that is somewhat reminiscent of L.A. Noire. You’ll appreciate this encounter if you’re a fan of Sherlock Holmes because it differs from the others.